|
Recruitment
Manager versus
Recruitment Director
P&A
Software Solutions markets two systems designed to manage staff
selection: Recruitment Manager and Recruitment Director. Both have
unique features and benefits.
Recruitment
Manager is an ‘out of the box’ solution designed for
small to medium sized organisations with a relatively low level of
recruitment (providing occasional access to data for one or two
users). The system enables users to manage details of applicants and
vacancies, as well as basic information on interviews, applicant
skills and medicals. Recruitment Manager is designed to consolidate
data with Personnel Manager.
Recruitment
Director is designed for organisations where larger volumes of
recruitment need to be managed, and where additional ‘custom’
functionality is required. Users manage details of candidates and
vacancies, agencies, interviews, referees, job offers and marketing
activities. This can be extended to include a wide variety of
additional areas. The Recruitment Director system consolidates data
with Personnel Director.
The
principal differences between the two systems are:
-
Recruitment
Director provides a multi-vacancy database (RM provides
single vacancy)
-
RD
provides financial management and reporting (feature not
provided in RM)
-
RD
facilitates the management and analysis of marketing
activities (not provided in RM)
-
RD
helps to manage contact with recruitment agencies (not
provided in RM)
-
A
web-publishing module is included with Recruitment
Director (not available for RM)
-
The
database technology employed differs (Paradox versus MS
SQL Server)
-
A
screen design facility is included with Recruitment
Director (not included in RM)
-
User
profiles can be defined in Recruitment Director (feature
not available in RM)
|
Multi-vacancy
database
Recruitment
Manager allows users to manage many databases, each containing
details of a single vacancy. Recruitment Director enables users to
record details of many vacancies within each database and produce
reports incorporating details from all vacancies. This means that
candidates can be considered as applicants for more than one
vacancy.
Financial
Management
Budgets,
costs and other financial information can be recorded and analysed
in Recruitment Director. Users can identify cost effective ways to
recruit different categories of staff. Where recruitment is run
centrally, the costs can be charged back to other ‘cost-centres’
within an organisation. None of this is possible in Recruitment
Manager.
Analysis
of Marketing Activities
Details
of recruitment campaigns and any associated marketing activities can
be recorded within Recruitment Director. The most productive ways to
generate suitable candidates for particular types of job (for a
particular region) can be derived from this information.
Management
of contact with Recruitment Agencies
With
Recruitment Director users can record details of any recruitment
agencies they deal with (including contact details, rates, areas of
expertise). Letters and e-mails can be generated from the system and
sent to contacts at these companies Where candidate details are
submitted via an agency, their records can reflect this and agency
costs can be monitored.
Web
Publishing
Recruitment Director comes with a web-publishing module. This
module publishes details of vacancies on an organisation’s web
site, enabling candidates to browse and apply for positions. A
comprehensive application form (including an optional
‘killer-questions’ page designed to enable organisations to
pre-filter applications) ensures that extensive details of
candidates are collected. This information is automatically recorded
in the RD database. Significant savings in recording and processing
applications can be made using this module.
Database
technology
Recruitment
Manager records data within a Paradox database. This database does
not require a database management system to be loaded and is quick
and easy to set up. Recruitment Director records data using
Microsoft SQL Server. MS SQL server offers enhanced data security,
provides a far higher data-capacity, enables access by higher
numbers of concurrent users, improves network performance, and
improves resilience and reliability.
Screen
Design
The
screen design functionality in Recruitment Director allows users to
modify existing screens, and add additional screens to their system.
They can record and manage a wide variety of information, and ensure
the system meets their needs as closely as possible. Changes made to
screens by users are fully integrated into the system and can be
accessed from the report writing and letter generating functionality
and managed in user-profile security. This screen design
functionality is not available in Recruitment Manager.
User
Profiles
User
accounts in Recruitment Manager have an access-profile associated
with them. These profiles are defined by a system administrator
(super-user) and determine the data (and functions) to which
individual users have access. No security profile management exists
in Recruitment Manager.
Features
|
Feature
|
Recruitment
Manager
|
Recruitment
Director
|
|
Date
Launched
|
2000
|
2002
|
|
Database
|
Paradox
|
MS
SQL Server
|
|
Screen
Designer
|
No
|
Yes
|
|
User
Access Profiles
|
No
|
Yes
|
|
Maximum
Users
|
Practical
limit of 3
|
Recommended
max 50
|
|
Maximum
Candidates
|
Max
250 recommended
|
Recommended
50000
|
|
Report
writing
|
Yes
|
Enhanced
Report Writer
|
|
Report
formats
|
Print
|
Print,
HTML, PDF, Excel
|
|
Web
Enabled
|
No
|
Yes
|
|
Integration
with MS Office
|
Yes
|
Yes
|
|
Selection
of letter data
|
Restricted
fields
|
Any
fields
|
|